BRAVE: Broadening the visual encoding of vision-language models
(2404.07204)Abstract
Vision-language models (VLMs) are typically composed of a vision encoder, e.g. CLIP, and a language model (LM) that interprets the encoded features to solve downstream tasks. Despite remarkable progress, VLMs are subject to several shortcomings due to the limited capabilities of vision encoders, e.g. "blindness" to certain image features, visual hallucination, etc. To address these issues, we study broadening the visual encoding capabilities of VLMs. We first comprehensively benchmark several vision encoders with different inductive biases for solving VLM tasks. We observe that there is no single encoding configuration that consistently achieves top performance across different tasks, and encoders with different biases can perform surprisingly similarly. Motivated by this, we introduce a method, named BRAVE, that consolidates features from multiple frozen encoders into a more versatile representation that can be directly fed as the input to a frozen LM. BRAVE achieves state-of-the-art performance on a broad range of captioning and VQA benchmarks and significantly reduces the aforementioned issues of VLMs, while requiring a smaller number of trainable parameters than existing methods and having a more compressed representation. Our results highlight the potential of incorporating different visual biases for a more broad and contextualized visual understanding of VLMs.
Overview
-
This paper introduces BRAVE, a method aimed at enhancing the visual understanding of Vision-Language Models (VLMs) by aggregating features from multiple vision encoders.
-
BRAVE is shown to provide state-of-the-art performance on tasks like image captioning and visual question answering (VQA), owing to its ability to produce a compact, comprehensive visual representation.
-
Extensive testing confirms that BRAVE improves the robustness of VLMs, particularly against challenges like out-of-distribution inputs and visual hallucinations.
-
The work suggests future directions for incorporating an even wider variety of vision encoders, potentially offering a path to more capable and versatile VLMs.
Broadening the Visual Capabilities of Vision-Language Models Through BRAVE
Introduction to BRAVE
Recent advancements in Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have significantly improved their performance across a variety of tasks requiring both visual and textual understanding, such as image captioning and visual question answering (VQA). These improvements are primarily due to enhancements in vision encoders and language models, which are then combined using various bridging techniques. Despite these achievements, VLMs continue to face challenges arising from the limitations of vision encoders, including their "blindness" to certain image features and susceptibility to visual hallucinations.
In response to these limitations, this paper introduces BRAVE (Broadening the Visual Encoding of Vision-Language Models), a method designed to leverage the diverse features of multiple vision encoders. BRAVE consolidates these features into a versatile representation that can be directly fed to a frozen language model (LM), achieving state-of-the-art performance on a range of captioning and VQA benchmarks, while requiring fewer trainable parameters and offering a more compact representation.
Key Contributions
- A comprehensive benchmarking of several vision encoders with different inductive biases, highlighting the varying performance across vision-language tasks and indicating no single encoder consistently delivers top performance.
- The introduction of BRAVE, an effective approach to aggregate features from multiple vision encoders into a singular, compressed, and contextual representation. BRAVE demonstrates improved performance and robustness against various benchmarks, signifying a more generalized and versatile visual understanding.
- A detailed ablation study of BRAVE, shedding light on the impact of its design choices, and offering insights potentially beneficial for future research in VLMs.
Broadening Visual Encoding in VLMs
The study commences with a comprehensive evaluation of VLMs configured with different vision encoders, revealing that no single encoder uniformly excels across diverse tasks. This observation, along with the realization that encoders with differing biases can yield surprisingly similar outcomes, paves the way for the development of BRAVE. BRAVE combines the strengths of various vision encoders to produce a more comprehensive visual representation, addressing the vision encoder limitations.
Methodology: BRAVE in Detail
BRAVE operates by integrating features from an arbitrary set of vision encoders using a Multi-Encoder Querying Transformer (MEQ-Former). This mechanism resamples and refines visual features into a compact form, effectively bridging the gap between vision encoders and the LM. The innovation lies in its efficient handling of diverse visual signals and its ability to maintain a smaller footprint in terms of trainable parameters compared to previous methods.
Empirical Validation and Analysis
Extensive experimentation demonstrates BRAVE's superior performance across various captioning and VQA tasks. Notably, it enhances the robustness of VLMs against challenges such as out-of-distribution inputs and visual hallucinations, areas where existing models have historically struggled. The paper also explore an ablation study that explores the impact of design choices within BRAVE, confirming the method's effectiveness and efficiency.
Implications and Future Research Directions
The findings underscore the potential of broadening the visual encoding within VLMs as a means to enhance their capability and performance. The success of BRAVE suggests that future work could explore incorporating a wider array of vision encoders, further diversifying the visual representations that VLMs can understand and interpret. Moreover, the approach highlights the significance of scaling along the vision axis, encouraging future research to balance the scaling across both vision and language components to achieve optimal VLM performance.
In conclusion, BRAVE represents a significant step forward in addressing the limitations of current VLMs, offering a more generalized and robust method for integrating visual and linguistic information. This work lays the foundation for further advancements in the field, pointing towards a future where VLMs can achieve even greater understanding and interpretation of the visual world.