Understanding Parents' Perceptions and Practices Toward Children's Security and Privacy in Virtual Reality
(2403.06172)Abstract
Recent years have seen a sharp increase in the number of underage users in virtual reality (VR), where security and privacy (S&P) risks such as data surveillance and self-disclosure in social interaction have been increasingly prominent. Prior work shows children largely rely on parents to mitigate S&P risks in their technology use. Therefore, understanding parents' S&P knowledge, perceptions, and practices is critical for identifying the gaps for parents, technology designers, and policymakers to enhance children's S&P. While such empirical knowledge is substantial in other consumer technologies, it remains largely unknown in the context of VR. To address the gap, we conducted in-depth semi-structured interviews with 20 parents of children under the age of 18 who use VR at home. Our findings highlight parents generally lack S&P awareness due to the perception that VR is still in its infancy. To protect their children's interactions with VR, parents currently primarily rely on active strategies such as verbal education about S&P. Passive strategies such as using parental controls in VR are not commonly used among our interviewees, mainly due to their perceived technical constraints. Parents also highlight that a multi-stakeholder ecosystem must be established towards more S&P support for children in VR. Based on the findings, we propose actionable S&P recommendations for critical stakeholders, including parents, educators, VR companies, and governments.
Overview
-
The study investigates parents' knowledge, perceptions, and practices regarding their children's security and privacy (S&P) in virtual reality (VR).
-
It involved semi-structured interviews with 20 parents to understand their awareness of S&P risks, mitigation strategies, and expectations from stakeholders.
-
Findings reveal a lack of immediate concern among parents for S&P in VR, a preference for active risk mitigation strategies, and a call for more effective controls and regulations.
-
The study suggests a multi-faceted approach to enhance S&P in VR, involving parents, educators, VR companies, and governments.
Understanding Parents' Perceptions and Practices Toward Children's Security and Privacy in Virtual Reality
Introduction
The rising popularity of virtual reality (VR) among children under the age of 18 has led to emerging concerns about their security and privacy (S&P). While the immersive nature of VR offers unique user experiences, it also poses distinct S&P risks. Recognizing that children rely heavily on their parents to navigate these risks, this study explore parents' knowledge, perceptions, and practices surrounding their children's S&P in the context of VR.
Methodology
To explore parents' perceptions and practices, a series of in-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted with 20 parents of VR users under the age of 18. The interviews aimed to understand parents' awareness of S&P risks in VR, their strategies for mitigating these risks, and their expectations towards VR companies, educators, and policymakers in enhancing children's safety in VR environments.
Findings
Parents' Awareness and Perceptions of S&P Risks
The study found that parents generally lacked immediate concern for their children's S&P specifically in VR, attributing this to a perception that VR technology is still in early stages and thus not widely adopted. Parents tended to prioritize concerns around physical health and well-being over S&P risks. However, when prompted, parents were able to articulate potential S&P risks, albeit with a greater emphasis on risks related to social interactions rather than data surveillance by VR companies.
Risk Mitigation Strategies
In terms of mitigating S&P risks, the study revealed that parents predominantly employed active strategies such as verbal education about general online S&P and setting usage rules. Passive strategies like using VR's built-in parental controls were infrequently utilized, mainly due to perceived technical limitations and a lack of awareness about these features.
Expectations Towards Stakeholders
Parents identified a multi-stakeholder ecosystem including themselves, VR companies, educators, and governments as responsible for child safety in VR. While acknowledging their central role, parents also highlighted the need for more effective and granular S&P controls in VR, clearer and mandatory S&P guidance from VR companies, and enhanced regulation and oversight by governments.
Implications and Future Directions
This study underscores a critical gap in parents' awareness and understanding of VR-specific S&P risks and the need for a concerted effort from all stakeholders to address these concerns. The findings suggest actionable recommendations for enhancing S&P support for children in VR, such as:
- For Parents and Educators: Augmenting their understanding of VR technologies and incorporating physical metaphors or references when educating children about S&P risks in VR.
- For VR Companies: Improving the usability and engagement of S&P controls and providing mandatory, clear, and engaging S&P guidance during onboarding.
- For Governments: Enhancing supervision over VR companies' S&P practices without unduly hindering the immersive experiences VR offers.
In conclusion, as VR continues to evolve and gain popularity among younger users, it is imperative for all stakeholders to proactively address the unique S&P challenges it presents. This study lays foundational groundwork for future research and policy development aimed at safeguarding children's security and privacy in virtual environments.
Create an account to read this summary for free: