Emergent Mind

Can Separators Improve Chain-of-Thought Prompting?

(2402.10645)
Published Feb 16, 2024 in cs.CL and cs.AI

Abstract

Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting is a simple and effective method for improving the reasoning capabilities of LLMs. The basic idea of CoT is to let LLMs break down their thought processes step-by-step by putting exemplars in the input prompt. However, the densely structured prompt exemplars of CoT may cause the cognitive overload of LLMs. Inspired by human cognition, we introduce CoT-Sep, a novel method that strategically employs separators at the end of each exemplar in CoT prompting. These separators are designed to help the LLMs understand their thought processes better while reasoning. It turns out that CoT-Sep significantly improves the LLMs' performances on complex reasoning tasks (e.g., GSM-8K, AQuA, CSQA), compared with the vanilla CoT, which does not use separators. We also study the effects of the type and the location of separators tested on multiple LLMs, including GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and LLaMA-2 7B. Interestingly, the type/location of separators should be chosen appropriately to boost the reasoning capability of CoT.

Overview

  • Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has been improved by introducing strategic use of separators (OT-SEP) to enhance LLMs' reasoning capabilities.

  • OT-SEP strategically places separators, like triple new lines, at the end of each exemplar within prompts to bolster comprehension and efficiency in solving complex tasks.

  • Empirical evaluation shows that OT-SEP yields higher performance in LLMs across a variety of reasoning tasks, with some separators being more effective than others based on the task context.

  • While showcasing benefits, the study also highlights the need for careful implementation of separators and acknowledges limitations and ethical concerns associated with reliance on LLMs.

Enhancing Chain-of-Thought Prompting with Strategic Use of Separators

Introduction to CoT Prompting and its Limitations

Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has emerged as a compelling strategy to enhance the reasoning capabilities of LLMs. By instructing LLMs to decompose complex problems into a series of intermediate steps before arriving at the final answer, CoT prompting mirrors human cognitive processes, facilitating improved problem-solving efficiency. Despite its effectiveness, a dense structure of prompt exemplars may induce cognitive overload in LLMs, potentially restraining their reasoning capacity. Drawing inspiration from human cognition, where strategic breaks significantly bolster comprehension and reasoning, the introduction of OT-SEP aims to alleviate such limitations.

Introducing OT-SEP: A Novel Strategy

OT-SEP represents a pioneering approach that strategically implements separators within CoT prompts. These separators, added at the end of each exemplar, serve to enhance the LLM's comprehension of its thought processes. Through empirical evaluation, OT-SEP has demonstrated notable improvements in LLM performance across various complex reasoning tasks, including arithmetic and commonsense reasoning benchmarks, when juxtaposed with the conventional CoT method which does not leverage separators.

Experimental Insights and Practical Applications

Extensive experimentation underscores the significance of choosing appropriate separators to amplify CoT's reasoning capabilities. The findings reveal that certain separators, specifically triple new lines (TripleSkip), substantially outperform others in boosting LLM reasoning accuracy. Interestingly, the effectiveness of separators can be contingent on the task, emphasizing the importance of contextual applicability. Moreover, the introduction of Heterogeneous CO T-SEP, which diversifies separators within a single prompt, has shown promise in scenarios where a single optimal separator is not apparent.

Future Perspective and Conclusion

The adoption of OT-SEP illustrates a meaningful advance in optimizing prompt design for LLMs. This research not only highlights the practical utility of separators in enhancing reasoning tasks but also opens avenues for integrating OT-SEP with other prompting techniques. Although the focus has thus far been on arithmetic and commonsense reasoning, the potential applicability of OT-SEP across a wider array of tasks warrants further exploration. Given the consistent improvement in LLM performance facilitated by OT-SEP, future endeavors may delve into the granular impact of separator types and their placements, catering to an array of LLM architectures and tasks.

Limitations and Ethical Considerations

It is pertinent to acknowledge the limitations intrinsic to CoT-based approaches, primarily the reliance on LLMs' ability to generate step-by-step reasoning, which may engender undue trust in their outputs. Furthermore, the necessity for precise separator placement to avoid diminishing accuracy emphasizes the need for meticulous implementation of OT-SEP. Lastly, while no direct ethical concerns are emanated from this research, the overarching implications of LLM reliance underscore the importance of cautious and critical application in real-world contexts.

Create an account to read this summary for free:

Newsletter

Get summaries of trending comp sci papers delivered straight to your inbox:

Unsubscribe anytime.