Mind your Language (Model): Fact-Checking LLMs and their Role in NLP Research and Practice

Much of the recent discourse within the NLP research community has been centered around LLMs, their functionality and potential -- yet not only do we not have a working definition of LLMs, but much of this discourse relies on claims and assumptions that are worth re-examining. This position paper contributes a definition of LLMs, explicates some of the assumptions made regarding their functionality, and outlines the existing evidence for and against them. We conclude with suggestions for research directions and their framing in future work.