On Counting (Quantum-)Graph Homomorphisms in Finite Fields of Prime Order (2011.04827v3)

Abstract: We study the problem of counting the number of homomorphisms from an input graph $G$ to a fixed (quantum) graph $\bar{H}$ in any finite field of prime order $\mathbb{Z}p$. The subproblem with graph $H$ was introduced by Faben and Jerrum [ToC'15] and its complexity is subject to a growing series of research articles, e.g. the work of Focke, Goldberg, Roth, and Zivn\'y [SIDMA'21] and the work of Bulatov and Kazeminia [STOC'22], subsequent to this article's conference version. Our contribution is threefold. First, we introduce the study of quantum graphs to the study of modular counting homomorphisms. We show that the complexity for a quantum graph $\bar{H}$ collapses to the complexity criteria found at dimension 1: graphs. Second, in order to prove cases of intractability we establish a further reduction to the study of bipartite graphs. Lastly, we establish a dichotomy for all bipartite ($K{3,3}\backslash{e}$, ${domino}$)-free graphs by a thorough structural study incorporating both local and global arguments. This result subsumes all results on bipartite graphs known for all prime moduli and extends them significantly. Even for the subproblem with $p$ equal to $2$, this establishes new results.