Computational Complexity of Certifying Restricted Isometry Property

Given a matrix $A$ with $n$ rows, a number $k<n$, and $0<\delta < 1$, $A$ is $(k,\delta)$-RIP (Restricted Isometry Property) if, for any vector $x \in \mathbb{R}^n$, with at most $k$ non-zero co-ordinates, $$(1-\delta) \|x\|_2 \leq \|A x\|_2 \leq (1+\delta)\|x\|_2$$ In many applications, such as compressed sensing and sparse recovery, it is desirable to construct RIP matrices with a large $k$ and a small $\delta$. Given the efficacy of random constructions in generating useful RIP matrices, the problem of certifying the RIP parameters of a matrix has become important. In this paper, we prove that it is hard to approximate the RIP parameters of a matrix assuming the Small-Set-Expansion-Hypothesis. Specifically, we prove that for any arbitrarily large constant $C>0$ and any arbitrarily small constant $0<\delta<1$, there exists some $k$ such that given a matrix $M$, it is SSE-Hard to distinguish the following two cases: - (Highly RIP) $M$ is $(k,\delta)$-RIP. - (Far away from RIP) $M$ is not $(k/C, 1-\delta)$-RIP. Most of the previous results on the topic of hardness of RIP certification only hold for certification when $\delta=o(1)$. In practice, it is of interest to understand the complexity of certifying a matrix with $\delta$ being close to $\sqrt{2}-1$, as it suffices for many real applications to have matrices with $\delta = \sqrt{2}-1$. Our hardness result holds for any constant $\delta$. Specifically, our result proves that even if $\delta$ is indeed very small, i.e. the matrix is in fact \emph{strongly RIP}, certifying that the matrix exhibits \emph{weak RIP} itself is SSE-Hard. In order to prove the hardness result, we prove a variant of the Cheeger's Inequality for sparse vectors.